The Norpro 3811 is the best overall documented stainless steel pie pan for most home bakers because its current maker page publishes a 9-inch top interior, 1.5-inch depth, 0.5-inch rim, 6.75-inch bottom interior, and mirror-finished stainless steel. Choose the American Metalcraft 918SS when its 18-gauge construction and narrower interior fit your recipe, or the RSVP Endurance MPIE-6 for a six-inch pie, pot pie, or quiche.
This is a short lineup because a product title that says stainless steel is not enough. The pan’s food-contact surface, diameter, rim, depth, care instructions, and oven guidance need to be traceable to the exact model. For a flat baking surface rather than a pie-shaped dish, start with our guide to stainless steel baking sheets.
Our stainless steel pie pan picks
| Pick | Material evidence | Documented geometry | Care and oven evidence | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Norpro 3811 | Stainless steel with a mirror finish; no grade or liner named | 9-inch top interior, 6.75-inch bottom interior, 1.5-inch side, 0.5-inch rim | Maker gives general dishwasher guidance; no numeric oven ceiling | Standard-size pies when interior measurements matter |
| American Metalcraft 918SS | Stainless steel, listed as 18 gauge | 9 1/8-inch top outside, 7 7/8-inch top inside, 6 7/8-inch bottom inside, 1-inch depth | Maker lists dishwasher-safe care; no numeric oven ceiling | A shallower pan with a documented rim and gauge |
| RSVP Endurance MPIE-6 | Durable stainless steel; exact listing separately states 18/8 | 6-inch diameter and 1.25-inch depth | Maker lists dishwasher-safe care; no numeric oven ceiling | Small pies, pot pies, and quiche |
The table uses published measurements, not a guessed usable volume. A top outside diameter, top interior diameter, and bottom interior diameter describe different parts of a sloped pan. Measure the pan you own and compare it with the maker’s exact dimensions before assuming that two nominally similar pans will hold the same crust.
1. Best overall: Norpro 3811 Stainless Steel Pie Pan
Norpro gives the most useful geometry in this lineup. Its current 3811 product page identifies a 9-inch top interior, a 0.5-inch rim, a 1.5-inch sloped side, and a 6.75-inch interior bottom diameter. It also describes a highly polished mirror finish and stainless steel construction. The maker does not publish an alloy grade, a separate liner, or a numeric oven-temperature limit.
The maker’s care language says the pan is easy to clean and can often be put in a dishwasher. Treat that as model-specific guidance rather than a universal dishwasher or heat rating. The exact Amazon record for Norpro 3811 (ASIN B000E3DTHE) returned a current listing snapshot on August 22, 2026, with a 4.7 rating from 659 reviews; those marketplace values and seller details can change.
Norpro 3811 Stainless Steel Pie Pan, 9-Inch
4.7 out of 5 (659 ratings, as of August 22, 2026)
A 9-inch Norpro stainless steel pie pan with documented rim, depth, and interior diameters.
- 9-inch top interior with a 0.5-inch rim
- 1.5-inch sloped side and 6.75-inch bottom interior
- Mirror-finished stainless steel; no alloy grade published
Pros
- Most detailed maker-published geometry in this lineup
- Standard-size profile is easy to compare with an existing dish
- Exact SKU and Amazon record reconcile
Cons
- Maker publishes no alloy grade or numeric oven ceiling
- Dishwasher language is general rather than a temperature rating
Considerations
Choose it when a standard-size pan with traceable interior measurements is more useful than an oven-temperature claim the maker does not publish.
2. Best for documented gauge and rim: American Metalcraft 918SS
American Metalcraft’s 918SS is a shallower, food-service-oriented option with unusually clear shape information. The current manufacturer page identifies durable 18-gauge stainless steel, a 9 1/8-inch top outside diameter, a 7 7/8-inch top inside diameter, a 6 7/8-inch bottom inside diameter, a 1-inch depth, and a wide rim. It also describes a closed-bead outer rim and lists dishwasher-safe care.
Those dimensions are not interchangeable with the Norpro’s 9-inch top interior. The American Metalcraft pan’s 7 7/8-inch top interior is the measurement to compare with a recipe’s crust size and your rack clearance. The maker does not publish a numeric oven limit or a stainless alloy designation beyond 18 gauge. The exact Amazon 918SS record (ASIN B00MPC7PFE) had a 4.6 rating from five reviews in the August 22, 2026 snapshot, a small sample that should not be treated as a performance test.
American Metalcraft 918SS Stainless Steel Pie Pan
4.6 out of 5 (5 ratings, as of August 22, 2026)
A shallow American Metalcraft stainless steel pie pan with published gauge, rim, and interior diameters.
- 9 1/8-inch top outside diameter
- 7 7/8-inch top interior and 6 7/8-inch bottom interior
- 18-gauge stainless steel with a closed-bead outer rim
Pros
- Maker publishes more rim and diameter detail than most listings
- 18-gauge construction is documented by the manufacturer
- One-inch depth suits a shallower pie-pan profile
Cons
- Top interior is narrower than the outside diameter suggests
- Small exact-ASIN review sample and no numeric oven ceiling
Considerations
Choose it only after comparing the published interior and depth with your crust, rack, and serving-dish measurements.
3. Best mini pie pan: RSVP Endurance MPIE-6
The RSVP Endurance MPIE-6 is the lineup’s small-format option. Its current maker page identifies a six-inch diameter, 1.25-inch depth, durable stainless steel construction, and dishwasher-safe care. The same page lists the maker SKU as MPIE-6 and describes small fruit pies, pot pies, quiche, and other small dishes as intended uses.
The exact Amazon record for RSVP MPIE-6 (ASIN B003FIH5RU) separately states an 18/8 material claim, but the current maker page does not publish a grade or certification. Keep the two statements separate. The maker does not publish a numeric oven limit, so follow the current recipe and product instructions rather than importing a temperature limit from another stainless pan. The dated marketplace snapshot showed a 4.6 rating from 181 reviews on August 22, 2026.
RSVP Endurance Mini Pie Pan, 6-Inch
4.6 out of 5 (181 ratings, as of August 22, 2026)
A six-inch RSVP Endurance stainless steel pie pan for small pies, pot pies, and quiche.
- 6-inch diameter and 1.25-inch depth
- Durable stainless steel named on the maker page
- Dishwasher-safe maker guidance; no numeric oven limit published
Pros
- Clear small-format dimensions
- Maker names several small-dish uses
- Exact maker SKU and Amazon record reconcile
Cons
- Too small for a standard full-size pie recipe
- Maker page does not publish alloy grade or certification
Considerations
Pick it for a deliberately small pie, pot pie, or quiche, and confirm that your recipe is written for a six-inch dish.
How we chose
This is a research-based roundup, not a hands-on bake-off or side-by-side test. I used one Bright Data Amazon discovery snapshot for stainless steel pie pans, then checked exact Amazon records for the three selected ASINs and current maker pages on August 22, 2026. I retained a product only when its exact listing could be reconciled with a current maker identity, stainless pan material, model or SKU, and published pie-pan geometry.
The selection priorities were:
- A stainless steel claim that applies to the pan itself, with no ambiguous coating or alternate material in the food-contact surface.
- Exact dimensions that distinguish top outside, top inside, bottom inside, rim, or depth measurements.
- Maker-published care guidance, keeping dishwasher and oven claims separate.
- A useful difference in format: standard home size, documented shallow geometry, or mini size.
- A live exact-ASIN record with dated rating and review-count fields, without treating marketplace feedback as controlled performance evidence.
The exact listings and maker pages do not all publish the same facts. Ratings, review counts, sellers, stock, variant packaging, and feature copy can change. Check the live model, dimensions, care instructions, and oven guidance before ordering. The page does not include prices because they are volatile and not part of the material or geometry decision.
What the evidence says about stainless steel pie pans
Food-contact material needs a model-level check
“Stainless steel” in a search title does not establish an alloy grade, a coating, or a certification. Norpro names stainless steel with a mirror finish, American Metalcraft names stainless steel and 18 gauge, and RSVP names durable stainless steel. None of the current maker pages names a separate liner or coating for the selected pan surface. That supports a narrow material description, not a universal food-safety guarantee.
The RSVP Amazon record includes an 18/8 statement that its maker page does not repeat. Treat that as an exact-listing field, not as a blanket claim about every RSVP product. If a live listing adds a coating, altered finish, or different model number, recheck the product before buying.
Diameter, rim, and depth change the fit
Use the maker’s measurement labels rather than a rounded product title. Norpro publishes top and bottom interior diameters and a rim. American Metalcraft publishes top outside, top inside, bottom inside, and depth. RSVP publishes a six-inch diameter and 1.25-inch depth but does not break out separate top and bottom interior measurements.
The crust, recipe, oven rack, and serving dish all need to fit the actual geometry. A stainless steel cooling rack or sheet pan can have a nominal size that differs from its usable interior. Measure the flat support area and the pan’s outside rim before assuming the two will nest.
Gauge and seam claims are often missing
American Metalcraft is the only selected maker that publishes an 18-gauge value. That is not a reason to infer a gauge for Norpro or RSVP, and it does not by itself establish an oven limit or baking result. The checked maker pages do not provide a comparable seam or weld specification for all three pans, so this roundup does not rank seam design.
If you are comparing several stainless bakeware pieces, keep the purchase boundary clear. Our stainless steel cookie-cutter guide covers cutters rather than pans, while our stainless steel mixing-bowl guide covers prep bowls with different geometry and care needs.
Care and oven guidance are separate fields
All three maker pages provide some dishwasher language, but none provides a numeric oven-temperature ceiling for the selected model. A dishwasher-safe statement is not an oven rating. Follow the exact maker and recipe instructions, avoid assuming that another pan’s heat limit transfers, and inspect the rim and surface after cleaning.
Mirror polish does not make bare stainless steel nonstick. Grease, parchment, or another release method should be chosen from the recipe and the maker’s care guidance. Do not add a scratch-sensitive coating assumption to a pan whose maker does not name one.
Frequently asked questions
Are stainless steel pie pans nonstick?
No. A polished or mirror finish is a surface description, not a nonstick coating or a promise of release. Use the recipe’s permitted release method and follow the exact product’s care instructions.
Does a nine-inch label tell me the usable pie size?
Not by itself. “Nine inch” can refer to top interior, top outside, or a rounded marketing label. Norpro publishes separate top and bottom interior measurements, while American Metalcraft publishes inside and outside diameters. Use the exact maker dimensions.
Can every stainless steel pie pan go in the dishwasher?
No universal rule applies. These three maker pages provide dishwasher guidance, but other models can include coatings, bonded parts, or different care instructions. Check the exact SKU and current maker page before using a dishwasher or abrasive cleaning method.
Bottom line
Choose the Norpro 3811 when you want the clearest standard-size geometry. Choose the American Metalcraft 918SS when its documented gauge, rim, and shallower interior fit your recipe. Choose the RSVP Endurance MPIE-6 for a six-inch pie, pot pie, or quiche. In every case, match the exact model’s food-contact description, dimensions, care, and oven guidance rather than treating stainless steel as a complete specification.
